Phoenix · 2025-04-23 · council
Phoenix City Council Formal Meeting - April 23, 2025
Summary
Summary Bullet Points
- The council unanimously approved nominations for mayor and city council boards and commissions.
- Item 14, related to a liquor license, was disapproved based on neighborhood protests.
- An intergovernmental agreement with Lavine School District for joint use of a school park was approved unanimously.
- The council passed the issuance of multifamily housing revenue bonds for Emery Heights with a 7-1 vote, with Councilwoman Hajj Washington abstaining.
- Nighthawk software licenses contract was approved with a 7-1 vote, with Councilwoman Hernandez voting against due to concerns about data privacy.
- Public comments highlighted issues related to civil rights, public parks management, and the need for better resources for homeless individuals.
Overview
During the April 23rd Phoenix City Council meeting, several key decisions were made, including the approval of board nominations and an intergovernmental agreement with Lavine School District. The council also addressed a controversial liquor license, which was disapproved due to community concerns. Additionally, discussions during public comment revealed ongoing issues regarding civil rights, public park management, and the challenges faced by homeless individuals in the city. Notably, the council's vote on the Nighthawk software raised significant concerns regarding data privacy among council members.
Follow-Up Actions or Deadlines
- Item 70 related to an unspecified topic is continued to May 7, 2025.
- Council members expressed the need for ongoing discussions on data privacy and the implications of the Nighthawk software.
- Further investigation into public park management and funding was suggested by several speakers during public comments.
Transcript
View transcript
Good afternoon. It is April 23rd. We appreciate you joining us. We'll begin today with an invocation. Please welcome Police Chaplain Harry Ston. Madame Mayor, ladies and gentlemen of the council and of the audience. Let us pray. Father God, we want to please you. We want to honor you and bring glory to your name. Sometimes we may not know exactly how to do that. So we pray for wisdom from heaven. We know that genuine respect for you is the beginning of wisdom. So teach us humility as we pray. Help us to remember that you are God and we are not. Help us to observe lessons from all that you have created, the truth principles that you have built into the universe. Let us learn from the wisdom of sewing and reaping the importance of a strong root system in life or learning from the industriousness of the ant. Father, give us knowledge of your holiness and help us to consider what you are doing in the world and through our lives. We know that you are absolutely sovereign and we cannot claim to be wise if we try to dodge your plans. Help us to view life from your perspective, always keeping an eye towards eternity. as you show us your majesty and your power. Father God, please grant these your servants on this council wisdom so that we may better magnify your name. And all this we pray. Amen. Amen. Uh thank you. Very powerful. Councilwoman Hud Washington will lead us into the pledge of allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it One nation under God, indivisible, liberty and justice for all. Thank you so much. Thank you, Councilwoman. We now will have a moment of silence to honor Jennifer Grondle. Jennifer served the city in many ways for many years and was instrumental in starting the city's first apprenticeship program. She also worked with us to raise the minimum wage for city employees and served on our our bond committee and and in so many other ways. Unfortunately, she has has been battling cancer and uh today we remember her with a a moment of silence. Thank you. I know Jennifer touched so many of us in this room. We'll now mo move to a a a different milestone of sort, a beginning. We are excited to welcome councilwoman Anna Hernandez for her first meeting on the dis and we'll recognize her to say a few words. Thank you, mayor. Um, thank you, council. I'm super excited to join everybody on this uh path forward in the next four years. Uh my name is Anon Hernandez for those of you watching at home and now I'm proud uh repres city council member for Phoenix District 7. Um you know I'm so excited about the work ahead. Um I'm you know looking forward to working with our mayor with the council to deliver really good things for the residents of Phoenix. Um also today happens to be my dad's birthday. Um so wishing him a very happy heavenly birthday. He's one of the biggest reasons why I actually sit on this on this dis now. So I'm looking I'm committed to doing really really good work um in his honor and in his remembrance moving forward. So thank you so much. will now call to order the formal meeting of the Phoenix City Council. Will the clerk call the role? Councilwoman Wardado here. Councilwoman Hernandez here. Councilwoman Haj Washington here. Councilwoman Pastor. Councilman Robinson here. Councilwoman Stark here. Councilman Wearing here. Vice Mayor O'Brien here. Mayor Ggo here. Mario Barahus is with us to provide Spanish interpretation. Mario, would you introduce your team? Yes, mayor. Thank you. Good afternoon. My name is Mario Vahas. I will I will be serving along with Eliz as interpreters for today's meeting. I'll take a moment now to introduce ourselves to our Spanish speaking audience. Thank you, mayor. Thank you. Will the city clerk please read the 24-hour paragraph? The titles of the following ordinance and resolution numbers on the agenda were available to the public at least 24 hours prior to this council meeting and therefore may be read by title or agenda item only. Ordinances number G7381, S51824 through 51863 and resolutions 22294 through 22298. I'll turn to the city attorney now to explain public comment. Thank you, mayor. Members of the public may speak for up to two minutes to comment on agenda items. Comments must be related to the agenda item and the action being considered by the council. General comments that go beyond the scope of the agenda item must be made in the citizen comment session at the end of the agenda. The city council and staff cannot discuss or comment on matters related to pending investigations, claims, or litigation. Additionally, any member of the public who appears before council in their capacity as a lobbyist must, as required by Phoenix City Code, disclose this fact before addressing council. The city code requires speakers to present their comments in a respectful and courteous manner. Profane language threats or personal attacks on members of the public, council members or staff are not allowed. A person who violates these rules may lose the opportunity to continue to speak. Thank you. Boards and commissions is next. Vice Mayor, do we have a motion? Yes, Mayor. I move to approve mayor and city council boards and commissions nominations. Second. We have a motion and a second. All those in favor, please say I. I. By a 70 vote, unanimously confirmed. We'll now conduct a swearing in ceremony. Please raise your right hand. I state your name. do solemnly swear do solemnly swear that I will support the Constitution of the United States that I will support the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution and laws of the state of Arizona and the Constitution and that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same that I will bear true faith and allegiance to the same and defend them against all enemies and defend them against all enemies, foreign and domestic. foreign and domestic. and that I will faithfully and impartially And I will faithfully and discharge the duties discharge the duties of the office of of the office of state your board Phoenix board design according to the best of my ability according to the best of my ability so help me God congratulations Congratulations to our commissioners. All four are folks who have served the city in many ways and we are excited to have you continuing to serve and bringing your great expertise to these important boards. We next go to the liquor license portion of our agenda. We serve an advisory role to the state of Arizona. Vice Mayor, do we have a motion? I move to approve items two through 14 except for item 14. Second. We have a motion and a second. Any comments? All those in favor say I. I. Any opposed? Passes unanimously. Item 14 is in council district 3. I'll turn to Councilwoman Stark. Thank you. and I don't need a report, but I did hear from several of my neighborhood leaders. So, I would like to recommend disapproval of this request based on neighborhood protest. Also noting that the applicant must resolve any pending city and of Phoenix building and zoning requirements and be in compliance with the city of Phoenix code and ordinances. Second. We have a motion and a second. Any comments? Roll call. Yes. Hernandez, yes. Hajj Washington, yes. Pastor Robinson, yes. Stark, yes. Wearing, yes. O'Brien, yes. GGO, yes. Passes 8 Z. Item 43 is next. Some good news for Lavine. It's an intergovernment is Nope. Oh, I'm sorry. Uh, city clerk, are we ready for ordinances, resolutions, new business planning, and zoning? Yes, mayor. Vice Mayor. I move to approve items 15 through 70 except the following items 44 and 48 noting that item 68 is withdrawn item 70 is continued to May 7th 2025 and excluding the following additional item for f virtual public comment item 43 and can the clerk confirm if there are any other items that should be excluded for in-person public comment mayor and vice mayor no other items to exclude Thank you. Second. Any comments? Roll call. Yes. Ernnandez, yes. Hodgej Washington, yes. Pastor, sorry. Robinson, yes. Stark, yes. Wearing, yes. O'Brien, yes. GGO, yes. Passes 8 Z. Item 43 is an intergovernmental agreement with Lavine School District for the joint use and maintenance of a school park site. Do we have a motion? I move to approve item 43. There's a motion and a second. We do have a member of the public here to speak. Michael Norton, the floor is yours. Mike Mr. Norton, floor is yours. Um, we are unable to hear you. You are unmuted. Michael Norton. Okay. Um, uh, he is marked in support of this item. I will turn to Councilwoman Hodge Washington who represents the area. Thank you, mayor. I just wanted to say I'm very excited to see this partnership move forward with Lavine Elementary School District. It helps bring a muchneeded school and park space to a growing part of our community. These types of collaboration make sure that families in district 8 continue to get access to a new K through8 school while also ensuring we keep space open for a new future park. I think it's a great example of how working together we can meet both today's needs and what our neighborhoods will need down the line. So, it's my pleasure to support this item. Thank you. Roll call. Yes. Ernnandez, yes. Haj Washington, yes. Robinson, yes. Stark, yes. Wearing, yes. O'Brien, yes. Yes. Passes 80. Item 44 is the issuance of multif multifamily housing revenue bonds for Emery Heights. Uh, do we have a motion? I move to approve item 44. Second. We have a motion and a second. Uh, Councilwoman Pastor did ask to that I share that she is in support of this item. We will note that Councilwoman Hutch Washington will not be participating in this vote. Does anyone have a comment before we vote? All right. More investment in housing. Roll call. Ward. Yes. Hernandez, yes. Robinson, yes. Stark, yes. Wearing, yes. O'Brien, yes. GGO, yes. Passes 70. Item 48 is Nighthawk software licenses contract. Do we have a motion? I move to approve item 48. We have motion. And a second from Councilwoman Stark. Any comments? Roll call. Was that a yes? Okay. And we'll recognize any council members who wish to explain their vote. Yes. Hernandez. Mayor, may I explain my vote? Please do. Thank you, Mayor. Um uh I saw the request uh for Nighthawk Software. I want to thank Chief Orandder um and his team for meeting with the D7 office this morning uh to talk through some of our concerns. Um I understand in theory what this software does and how it helps uh Phoenix police solve cases. I also have a lot of questions around the data collection and the protection of constitutional rights in this moment. Um access to our personal information and it's an area that I take very seriously. Um and given the current administration, the current federal administration um and how data is being used to undermine our constitutional rights in real time is extremely concerning to me. um still have some concerns and some questions around the software, what it's capable of, and how we are protecting our people and their rights. Um so, as a result of those concerns, I will be airing on the side of caution for the people in my community and their rights and voting no. Um but I do look forward to continuing the conversations with the chief and his team to understand how software like this can help us um protect um our residents of Phoenix. Thank you. I vote no. Haj Washington, yes. Pastor, sorry. Robinson, yes. Stark, yes. Wearing, yes. O'Brien, yes. GGO, yes. Passes 71. We next go to the public comment portion of our meeting, and I'll turn to the city attorney to explain that portion. Thank you, mayor. During citizen comment, members of the public may address the city council for up to three minutes on issues of interest or concern to them. Excuse me. The citizen comment session is limited to 30 minutes. The Arizona open meeting law permits the city council to listen to the comments that prohibits council members from discussing or acting on the matters presented. Thank you. We'll begin with John Foresight followed by Steve Brittle. Good afternoon. I'm John Foresight. Want to apologize. I said I'd be at the council meeting last time and I missed it for Well, life happens sometimes. Last time I was here, I was talking about civil rights. Human rights. Inalienable rights. Inalienable means rights that cannot be taken away. Civil rights aren't black rights. They're not American rights. They're human rights. We have a human right, civil right problem going on here in the city of Phoenix, and no one wants to seem to talk about it. A month ago when I was at the meeting, Wallace and Ladmo got more play than civil rights. I came here today to talk about Michael Kenyon. But I quickly want to address a recent article about Officer Timothy Clark. Now, like many Americans, Officer Clark made a mistake after a Dbacks game. He got a little too excited and went on a drunken rampage. He made a mistake, but he's in front of the Arizona Review Board right now, possibly to lose his certificate. I don't believe a mistake deserves to be losing your certificate to be law enforcement. Now, Michael Kenyon, he was an innocent man. Four officers for four minutes held him on the ground and an August afternoon parking lot, burned the entire front of his body, scarred him for life. Passerby thought an injured animal was screaming for help. The passerby had more humanity than four Phoenix police officers. That's just unacceptable. Our service members are held to a Geneva convention. These Geneva conventions are stronger than what it seems like we expect out of our officers here in the city of Phoenix. We don't want to talk about this. And I understand why. We live in a democracy, a republic if you want me to be specific. We have to talk about our issues. We can't hide behind a lawsuit. So, I'm going to talk about I'm going to bring it to light. I want to finish with ex-chief Michael Sullivan. Now, when he resigned, I initially was excited. I said, "Okay, a new direction for Phoenix." But what endured after his resignation was chaos. And chaos forms due to the lack of leadership. Michael Sullivan was interim police chief for two and a half years during a federal investigation for civil rights violations. This council, city manager, and the mayor, you couldn't make a decision in two and a half years. I mean, that's just unfair to Michael Sullivan. Michael Sullivan's taking the golden bullet for the city of Phoenix. That's unjust. That's unfair. and in a democracy. I'm coming forward and saying the wrong people are being held accountable in the city of Phoenix. Thank you. Steve Riddle is next, followed by Jerry, Mayor and Council. um appreciate the time here. I have not been here for a long time. In my many years here, I've seen some very strange things happen at the city of Phoenix. And one in particular that has me really concerned is what has happened to our public parks system. the only city in the whole metro area where the city council somehow gave up its abilities to control the parks and a independent body that is not answerable to the public has been somehow created with a slush fund with money that can't be accounted for. and do you have a fudiciary duty over our park system and I just don't understand what possess the council to allow this strange development when I I do a lot of enforcement. I've done 95 federal enforcement cases. I won them all in the environmental arena. But I know a scam when it's being put together and a slush fund and I've seen some things. One of our previous uh lawsuits was against the parks department. They were busy trying to build a golf course for Scottsdale Resort using our taxpayer dollars. We stopped that from happening. That was about 15 years ago. But these disturbing incidences keep coming up and I just wonder how did it happen that we would get this strange animal that no other city has and you have a parks board that's not accountable to anybody and they've been appointed and there's a lot of things going wrong there. I think it's time for a federal investigation to see where the money's been going. Thank you. Jerry is next, followed by Missy. Jerry Vanas, uh, since our parks department and our parks board don't seem willing to provide updates on the South Mountain renovation project, which started back in 2016 with the appropriation of $23 million. Uh here we are nine years later. Uh it's upwards of $50 million has been spent at South Mountain by the the parks department own admission. Unfortunately, they can't produce contracts for several of these projects. Uh there's expenses, you know, over $7 million for a mystery house that nobody can explain. Uh it looks like a giant bait and switch to the public. We're getting no answers. Uh there's more. There's more to come. We're looking into a new project that doesn't seem to have been authorized. They haven't produced a contract. They haven't produced the environmental permits that are needed. Uh and we're getting people coming on board left and right. We're going to put together our own budget accounting of where the money has gone. And uh we've got a forensic CPA. We've got three attorneys working on this. Uh we're not going to let up because we're getting no answers from the parks department. Thank you. Missy is next, followed by Lisa. Hi, Mayor Hill Council. It was nice to see everybody at the inaugural um celebrations and I got to speak to almost all of you there about what I'm going to talk about tonight or today. Um last week I or the week before I wasn't at this meeting and was the I had missed a meeting in eight months. Um I got probably about 10 messages through just um social media and text message of why weren't you there? What's going on? are you still supporting the cats? What's happening? And um it reminded me how important it is for me to continue to be here and how inspiring it is for other people. It keeps them going. Um but I had a family emergency and I wasn't able to be here. So when those people were asking me why weren't you here? I'm like I'm I'm coming. I'm coming every two weeks. I'm talking. But what is actually getting done? Not much. I'm just talking and getting annoyed and you guys are getting annoyed. So, I have requested I've already sent the message into the mayor. I've requested a proclamation for a feline appreciation day. This might sound super silly, but I believe that words can be more important than money sometimes. And for you to back a feline appreciation day for the entire city where schools can celebrate, schools can have be have education, we can have um different organizations be involved. That's huge. And what what I want is there to be awareness and education. And this can be something that can actually do something. It will bring other businesses. It'll bring other communities all together for the love of the cats. Thank you. Lisa is next, followed by Elizabeth. Hello, my name is Lisa Spragens and this is my first time addressing the City Council of Phoenix, but it won't be my last. I'm 64 years old and I moved to Arizona in 2019 thinking I was easing my way into retirement, but that didn't quite happen. I still run my multif family housing companies in New Jersey, Michigan, and Kansas. But nearly two years ago, something unexpected happened that changed the direction of my life. Around the time of the horrific Chandler 55 animal abuse case, I stumbled across an Instagram account called Handover Rover. I started following them and I was moved by a story about Jerry, a dog who had been shot in the spine and couldn't walk. They were raising money to buy a water treadmill to help him recover. So, I made a sizable donation. Not long after, I saw a post of them feeding feral cats in their neighborhood, and I decided to send some cat food from their Amazon wish list. But accidentally, it got shipped to my house. And I had no connection to Handover Rover except Instagram. But I remember getting a nice thank you email after my donation and it had a phone number. I called and Coco answered and I said, "Hi, it's Lisa Spragens." And I heard her call out to someone, "It's Lisa Spraggins." That kind of cracked me up. And uh and I told her about the mixup and she gave me an address in Phoenix and uh to where I could drop off the food. When I got there, I was surprised to see such a small house. And this was where they were running their whole nonprofit rescue operation. And I couldn't get that image out of my head after I left. And I kept asking myself, how can I help these two women and all the animals in their care? I continued listening to their lives on Instagram and uh I could tell they were overwhelmed and yet they were still so fiercely committed. They spoke about a dream of building a rescue ranch. In March of 2024, I texted after one of their live videos asking to hear more about that ranch, but I didn't get a response. So, I started searching online for properties, thinking that if maybe they moved their operation north, maybe I could volunteer and I could be of some help. I sent the listings some listings to them and said, "Is this the kind of ranch that you're uh looking for? And I'll call my real estate agent." In less than a month, I'd purchased a property that was the future home of the Handover Ranch. I thought I was going to retire, but instead, I became a benefactor for animal rescues. And somehow, I think I've been rescued, too. My life has new purpose, and one that's been rewarding as anything I've ever done. And the greatest bonus, I think, is gaining a family and a community of the most dedicated human beings I've ever known. If one person can make this kind of a difference, [Music] feel free to finish your thought. If one person can make this kind of a difference with one small rescue with 40 animals, imagine what a city council could do for the thousands of animals still suffering in the Phoenix streets. And maybe you could start by bless you throwing support behind uh Arizona. Thank you. Elizabeth Venibal is next followed by Coco Garcia. Hello. Uh can't miss a meeting. Um we have uh some speakers today on sort of more general issues. Um uh I wanted to encourage you all though to um consider ways that you can um uh maybe expand pre-existing programs that meet community needs while also meeting the needs of people that experience homelessness. There are a lot of um resources that already exist um that can meet some of the heat needs, you know. Um, I like the idea that you have of expanding the library hours. I think that's actually a really really um, positive idea because those facilities already exist. You know, there's less cost in um, you know, expending those hours. Um, I think it's also really important to consider the role of um, for example, parks and other services. you know, sometimes the bathrooms aren't open. Um, and sometimes there can be minimal costs to accommodate um the needs of people on the streets and then you don't have as much, for example, sanitation concern, you know. Um, I think that these often times are services that benefit the entire community, especially if they're framed that way, if they're operated that way, and so they can provide sort of ancillary services um, sort of without being as obvious, right? And being more inclusive. So, I know that's sort of like a random short comment. I'm not even going to use my time that much. Um, I've talked to you guys a lot in the past like month or two. So, um, but we have some some new speakers from fun for empowerment and and they'll have different perspectives. So, thank you. Coco is next, followed by Candace. Hello. My name is Koko Garcia. I'm the founder of Handover Rover, a small rescue here in Phoenix, Arizona. uh to piggyback what Lisa was speaking of uh with with Bill 1658. Excuse me, I've got a a cold. Um several months ago, we were here and we came to you guys with a horrific situation regarding a local rescue that had been and continues currently to abuse and neglect puppies, babies, in some of the worst ways. And I'm not here to go on about this rescue, even though somebody should. um what they were doing was unimaginable and a lot of those animals were dying of illnesses that could have been treated in their care. Sorry, I lost my train of thought. They they take in so many animals that they they don't have enough time or room to do anything but just house these these puppies and they flip them for a profit. And uh it's the opposite of what a nonprofit stands for. And that the kennels are stacked kennel upon kennel with urine and feces dripping from the top going down to the bottom. I don't even want to talk about it because it's that horrific. Um the only reason I know this is this was brought to our attention. We were asked if we could step in and help. And at the time I had one of my girls that had some free time and this rescue was hiring. And I said, "Do you want to go down and see if they'll hire you? You don't have to say who you are. Just get some footage and let's see if these accusations, you know, if this is real. It was real and it was worse than what we could have imagined. So, we immediately went to Arizona Humane. They got down there. They brought down the police department. And unfortunately, even though Arizona Humane said this, this, and this is a citable offense, the police department did not site anything. And they went down a second time and they still did not site anything. And when I asked what was going on, Arizona Humane said, you know, this they don't see a lot of this. The the laws are fairly gray and there's just not enough education for the police department. Um, and it's kind of a touchy subject. Where SB1658 comes in is it clearly defines some of those areas that are currently very gray and it makes it very, very effortless for our police department to do their job. And then we're not running around in this vicious circle of pointing the finger who does what. Uh 1658 asks for drinkable water, not urine and their water dish. It asks that their housing be adequate that they can stand up and move around without being cramped. And it asks that they have food fit for that species. So we're just here today to ask you when that bill arises if you guys would back that. And I'll follow up with emails. It's bill 1658. Thank you. Thank you. Candace is next, followed by Melvin. Hi, my name is Candace Johnson. I'm recently living on the streets for like 5 years. I take care of my husband in a wheelchair. We constantly getting all our stuff thrown away from the police department and um anywhere we go and use the restroom. I think I think we should be able to have like some kind of porties or something so we can be able to use the restroom cuz it's kind of hard taking care of him in a wheelchair, you know. So, um, and then if you guys can just hear me out about housing, if you guys can give us some kind of resources to where we can go for some kind of housing so we can get off the streets. Thank you. Thank you. Is there someone who might be able to follow up on on that one? Thank you. Melvin is next, followed by Sunday. Could we take the microphone to him, please? My name is Melvin Sterns and uh I want to talk about uh parks. We me and my wife be so tired we going to the park sit on the grass in the shade be so hot they don't want nobody sitting they don't want the homeless sitting in the in the shade on the grass or in or in the park can't even use the restrooms yeah pretty much all right thank you for The important testimony Sunday will be next, followed by Teresa, our final speaker. Sunday, can you hear us? We cannot hear you. Yes. All right. Now we can hear you. Can you? Yep. The floor is yours and now we can hear. Hi. Hi. Thank you. My name is Sunday Jones. I'm calling from Los Angeles, California. Um, on February the 7th, I drove here from Los Angeles to the Maricopa County Medical Examiner's Office to pick up my deceased son and I drove him back across state lines here in a pickup truck by myself here to Los Angeles, California for burial. That was February the 7th. Um my son is um parked right down the street from the funeral home where my son is still there in the refrigerator. On February the 1st um the Maricopa County Sheriff, I believe Sheriff's Department was called out to a motel there in Phoenix where my son's body had been discovered deceased. My son had been discovered deceased. in a motel room. And the problem that I have is that um when I did get the medical examiner's report back here recently, it it you know it was determined that my son passed away from a fentanyl overdose. I am um really struggling with the fact that number one um when the police responded or the sheriff's department responded there was no investigation surrounding my son's death. Also, well, because of that, um, there's been no one that's been held accountable or that could possibly through an investigation be held accountable for my son's death, meaning the perpetrator who sold my son the fentanyl product that cost his life. and more so uh my family is bracing for any type of justice for my son and for ourselves. We don't know where that's going to come from because there was no investigation. Um there was no evidence collected. There was evidence available where he was found deceased. There was his phone. There was lift records um that we have. Also, I don't have unfortunately I don't have insurance for my son. I didn't have burial insurance for him because my son's death wasn't investigated. He's not considered a a victim of a crime and therefore we're not entitled to victim of crimes compensation w which would provide for his funeral and burial. I I would like to know why. Uh, very sorry for your loss, Mrs. Jones. We will see if we can get you an an update on this um and where it is with the police department or the joint sheriff. Okay, that we will try to see if it is with county or or city, but see if we can't get you more information. Teresa will be our final speaker. Good afternoon, Mayor and Council. I would like to make a comment on the budget it. I have seen several items on the budget that are postponing IT things like software, application, training, and equipment. As a past government employee of IT, I have seen servers and systems that get put off and put on the back burner for financial because budget needs to be cut somewhere in the agency. It's sometimes about systems running smooth to protect our data. And I ask for you as you read through this that you see it in a different light. The world we live in now as we've seen Maricopa County system get hacked for us to just take a step back and re-evaluate. Are we doing everything we can to make sure we have all that we need? Data is so important. Our information is important out there. I also would like to congratulate our newly elected. As I watched your inauguration speeches and being sworn in, it was nice to see the viewpoint overall that each of you had for the city. And to those who mothers could not be there, I had such a heart because I'm fortunately I'm part of that club as well. But I just wanted you to know that we are seeing who you are and are very excited of what this next few years is going to look like for us. I want to end with thanking all of those in emergency services from the 911 and the crisis centers to the police and fire department, everything in between. Sometimes they don't hear thank you. But I want you to know each of those people out there that you're appreciated and thank you for choosing to work in the city of Phoenix. I pray for your strength and your protection. I thank you for your time, council, and I look forward to the new year, shall we say, of getting through the summer um protecting and hopefully preventing more homeless deaths as there are more resources out there. I just pray that they can reach out and take advantage of what is there. Thank you. Thank you. We are adjourned. Throwing out the first pitch today is none other than Kell Kendrick. Kel Kendrick. Let's give him a round of applause.